The Ur-Quan Masters Discussion Forum

The Ur-Quan Masters Re-Release => General UQM Discussion => Topic started by: Valaggar on March 13, 2007, 02:34:05 pm



Title: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Valaggar on March 13, 2007, 02:34:05 pm
Yes, I really mean it! I am genuinely repentant of the crime I commited abandoning my project (see "My voice pack" in my signature).  :'(
But since the interest in my voicepack was so minute, so inexistant, I'd say that you didn't like my interpretation.
That's why I made this thread: I want to hear how you would imagine a perfect Utwig voice! And don't forget the Slylandro, of course - that voice is certainly not fit for a gasbag.

And if you liked my interpretation, just say it, don't be afraid!  ;)


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Koowluh on March 13, 2007, 04:56:09 pm
I actually like the current Utwig. Ok, I'm not listening to them long because they depress me, but that's the whole idea behind the Utwig to begin with.

As for the Slylandro, I can imagine that the voice is actually not a Slylandro itself, but a mimiced voice from the communications satellite. Real Slylandro may not have an actual voice you know....


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: meep-eep on March 13, 2007, 08:44:07 pm
Maybe you should mail Stephen Hawking that his voice doesn't match his person.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Novus on March 14, 2007, 10:41:49 am
Maybe you should mail Stephen Hawking that his voice doesn't match his person.
He already knows that he sounds like an American (http://www.hawking.org.uk/text/disable/disable.html). At least he doesn't sound (too much) like a Dalek.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: meep-eep on March 14, 2007, 04:14:53 pm
Not liking the current Utwig voice isn't the same as wanting a new one.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Novus on March 14, 2007, 04:35:56 pm
Not liking the current Utwig voice isn't the same as wanting a new one.
Exactly. It's supposed to get on your nerves, so I, for one, wouldn't want it changed (much).


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: countchocula86 on March 14, 2007, 06:56:20 pm
I agree with the voice changes, specifically the Slylandro. Sure you can explain it off as communcations technology, but thats the easy way out. I think they need a more diverse and interesting voice.

The Utwig too should be changed, they covered the depressing just fine, but the pitch isnt right.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: countchocula86 on March 14, 2007, 07:03:22 pm
I'm not really sure what I want haha, I need to play the game and talk to them again before I can definitivly say what I would prefer to see.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Cedric6014 on March 15, 2007, 11:36:07 am
The Utwig too should be changed, they covered the depressing just fine, but the pitch isnt right.

I find the whiny Utwig voice quite hilarious now. I admit it was not what I expected after playing PC version without voice - was expecting something more morose.

However i'm personally happy with how it is. It amuses me as much as any other voice and I consider it believeable pre and post Ultron fixing.

2 cents!


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: countchocula86 on March 16, 2007, 06:11:25 pm
Have you uploaded the audio?


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Valaggar on March 16, 2007, 08:27:41 pm
Alright, file transfer to SaveFile is complete. Now you can download it much easily.
Download Link:
http://www.savefile.com/files/557939 (http://www.savefile.com/files/557939)


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: countchocula86 on March 16, 2007, 11:13:14 pm
The Slylandro voices are not bad, but they're too breathy, and whats up with the accent :P

The Utwig just sound really distorted to me lol.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Gaeamil on May 27, 2007, 07:30:37 am
You know, I finally wanted to look at that, but now it's gone!

As for what I think oughta be redone, out of these, is just the Utwig AFTER they regain the Ultron.  The Slylandro voice rather well matches a race young and naive in the ways of the greater galaxy.

Pardon the extreme lateness in posting this.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Valaggar on May 27, 2007, 09:16:18 am
You know, I finally wanted to look at that, but now it's gone!

As for what I think oughta be redone, out of these, is just the Utwig AFTER they regain the Ultron.  The Slylandro voice rather well matches a race young and naive in the ways of the greater galaxy.

Pardon the extreme lateness in posting this.
For the Utwig, we are going to have Lance's pack soon. (As for redoing only the Utwig after they regain the Ultron, the sudden change in voice would be too strange)
The Slylandro - yes, they're not bad at all, but they sound a bit bumpy.

PS: Just found something hilarious: The Supox say "They are beyond ecstatic, well into the range of rapture or perhaps even pegged on epiphany. If you wish to learn the true depth of their joy, talk with them yourself." in response to "So how are the Utwig liking their Ultron?". And if you heed their advice and speak with Greg Johnson's Utwig... you are REALLY convinced that they're happy...  ::)


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Simon K on May 27, 2007, 03:43:26 pm
Quote
The Supox say "They are beyond ecstatic, well into the range of rapture or perhaps even pegged on epiphany. If you wish to learn the true depth of their joy, talk with them yourself." in response to "So how are the Utwig liking their Ultron?". And if you heed their advice and speak with Greg Johnson's Utwig... you are REALLY convinced that they're happy...   ::)
Personally I thought that was one of the most amusing jokes in the game.

Get the player all excited over hearing what an ecstatically happy Utwig sounds like -- only to have him realize that the "annoying whiny emo kid" is just naturally how the Utwig sound. Classic.

I don't understand this strange fixation some of you guys seem to have with removing comedy from the game.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Valaggar on May 27, 2007, 03:55:03 pm
Quote
The Supox say "They are beyond ecstatic, well into the range of rapture or perhaps even pegged on epiphany. If you wish to learn the true depth of their joy, talk with them yourself." in response to "So how are the Utwig liking their Ultron?". And if you heed their advice and speak with Greg Johnson's Utwig... you are REALLY convinced that they're happy...   ::)
Personally I thought that was one of the most amusing jokes in the game.

Get the player all excited over hearing what an ecstatically happy Utwig sounds like -- only to have him realize that the "annoying whiny emo kid" is just naturally how the Utwig sound. Classic.

I don't understand this strange fixation some of you guys seem to have with removing comedy from the game.
The problem is NOT comedy as a whole, just this particular application of it.
The Utwig were initially designed as a race of serious, ceremonious people, not emo. Indeed, they only share some tangential characteristics with emo people.
Using such a whiny voice for them has naturally enraged all people who loved and understood the Utwig.

Plus, what's up with their depression caused by the destruction of the Ultron if they're casually depressed?! Fake depression?!!!


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Simon K on May 28, 2007, 09:44:48 pm
Quote
The Utwig were initially designed as a race of serious, ceremonious people, not emo. Indeed, they only share some tangential characteristics with emo people.
And yet, the game's creators (who, I assume, know more about how their creation was "initially designed" than people hanging around on some Web forum) decided to have this "serious, ceremonious" race speak in a whiny, annoying voice. They even went so far as to base one of the jokes in the game on that.

Quote
Plus, what's up with their depression caused by the destruction of the Ultron if they're casually depressed?! Fake depression?!!!
But that's the whole joke. Their voice is not whiny because they're depressed, that's just how they sound. They sound like that when they're ecstatically happy as well. You only realize that their annoying tone is not a depressed tone when you fix the Ultron, and thus get to hear what a happy Utwig sounds like.

That a human might interpret their tone as being depressed doesn't *make* them depressed any more than a Yehat's accent makes him Scottish.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Smaug on May 29, 2007, 04:51:59 am
Quote
I don't understand this strange fixation some of you guys seem to have with removing comedy from the game.

Comedy that isn't funny isn't comedy. It's just some words being spoken or read.

Furthermore, the comedic elements of the StarControl universe are very clearly directed. They're centered around some races and circumstances, while others are very serious.

In a voice-less StarControl 2, the Utwig are well outside of these comedic elements, very much like the Ur-Quan, Chmmr, and several others. They very clearly aren't the Thraddash, Spathi, Umgah, Druuge, etc.

Imagine if the Chmmr spoke with a cowardly voice (it's funny, right? They're hiding under a slave shield, get it?), and the damage it would do to their character.

Quote
who, I assume, know more about how their creation was "initially designed" than people hanging around on some Web forum

Two words: George Lucas.

Some people make good things by accident. Or later have revisionings of something that was just fine to begin with, and turn it into something weaker.

The point is this: a thing should be judged on its own merits, not the deification of those who created it.

Quote
But that's the whole joke.

It's only a joke if its funny. And, quite frankly, it isn't.

Furthermore, I would point out that the game, StarControl 2 was designed, built, shipped, and purchased by many well before any alleged jokes based on voice acting. The voice acting version should not fundamentally alter the ideas created by the non-voice acted version.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Simon K on May 29, 2007, 02:40:16 pm
Hey Smaug,

Quote
Furthermore, the comedic elements of the StarControl universe are very clearly directed. They're centered around some races and circumstances, while others are very serious.

Yes -- the Chmmr, for instance, are very serious. As are both kinds of Ur-Quan.

But the Utwig? They broke the Ultron because they *dropped it on the ground*. Their dialogue, even without the voice acting, pokes fun at the exaggerated "woe is me", Goth / emo-style self-conscious "depression" stereotype. They used to have Masks of Natural Bodily Excretions hung at every lavatory, and based their courting rituals on wearing Veils of Flirtatious Prancing, and Lewd Monocles. I'd say that humour is quite integrated to the treatment of the Utwig race, even without the voice acting.

Quote
Two words: George Lucas. [...] a thing should be judged on its own merits, not the deification of those who created it.

I completely agree, but Valaggar was basing his argument on "initial design", and I reckon PR3 and FF know more about the Star Control initial design than either of us does. That doesn't make them gods.

I think Star Control 3 is to the Star Control franchise what the prequels were to Star Wars.

Quote
I would point out that the game, StarControl 2 was designed, built, shipped, and purchased by many well before any alleged jokes based on voice acting. The voice acting version should not fundamentally alter the ideas created by the non-voice acted version.

Star Control 2 for the PC was originally shipped in 1992. The 3DO version, which introduced the voice acting, was (if memory serves) shipped in 1993, not very long after the 3DO was released to the public. I don't think the voice acting version alters the ideas created by the non-voice-acted version, at least as far as the Utwig are concerned -- I first played the game without voices, and came to view the Utwig as a not-entirely-serious race anyway (see above). The anticipation of hearing what an "ecstatic Utwig" sounds like, only to find that they whine even when happy, was an entertaining added joke when I played the game with voices.


Title: Re: This time I'm SERIOUSLY considering to redo the Utwig&Slylandro voices!!!
Post by: Valaggar on May 29, 2007, 03:38:52 pm
The impression that the Utwig cast upon me is that of a generally seriously-treated race, with moments of comedy (which, contrasting so much with the rest of their portraying, is even funnier - such as the "We have been directed to attack... YOU! No, wait, that's wrong, sorry. We attack... YOUR ENEMIES! The Ur-Quan and the Kohr-Ah. No, wait, that's not quite right either... What?! Oh, okay... We must strike ONLY the black ships, only the Kohr-Ah!").
So a serious voice works better, contrasting with the silly, funny things they say sometimes. Too much stress on a good joke makes it "wrap around" to a bad joke.