Um, copyright is not eternal. Right now, the US copyright for software made for hire is 95 years from publication or 120 years from creation, whichever is shorter.
Um, I knew that... however, for all intents and purposes it is indefinate, because in 95 years it will be impossible to play a game created today as it is today... it would have to undergo major porting.
So, assuming the law doesn't change again, is it wrong 95 years from now to copy Starcontrol 2? It wouldn't be illegal. Or is it 5 years from now it's wrong, but 95 years it isn't? Why? Because the law says so? Or is it because 95 years from now Starcontrol 2 will have no value and 5 years it still will? Why 95 years? Why not more, why not less?
Because, as you said, corporate greed has lengthened the copyright.
If I made a machine that made duplicates of apples at practially no cost, nobody would accuse me of stealing from apple growers (except maybe the apple growers.) In fact, I'd be hailed as the savior of mankind, I'd think, eliminating hunger!
However, as you said, a physical object is not the same as an intellactual one. Stick to one thing or the other. As for the intellectual ones, look at Lukipela's example of photocopying a book -- EVEN an out of print one. It is stealing, for the same reasons that software piracy -- EVEN of an out of print game, is stealing.
Copyrights were intended as a way for artists to make money off of their creations. After they've made their money, those works go into the public domain. I think that copyrights have been extended way too far by corporate greed. Disney has made their money on Mickey Mouse. They need to let him go. He belongs to all of us now.
A couple corrections: After they've made their money, those works SHOULD go into the public domain.
Mickey Mouse does NOT belong to all of us. Disney is still very much making money off of Mickey Mouse, and to make Mickey Mouse public property
would lose them money.
and now, a message to EVERYONE!
>!>!>!>!>!>!>!>!>!>!>!>!>!>!
YES! I think copyrights should be for a shorter time!
BUT! They are not, and copying a copyrighted work without the owner's permission is illegal! No matter what the circumstances, doing so is wrong!
[/soapbox]